Opera News

Opera News App

Today In Supreme Court - Details

AgyarkwahJustice(nanabagist)
By AgyarkwahJustice(nanabagist) | self meida writer
Published 23 days ago - 9910 views

14TH UPDATE ON ELECTION PETITION HEARING-9TH FEBRUARY, 2021.


At exactly 9:30 am today, hearing commenced. After the announcement of parties and Counsel, the Court called upon Counsel for the 1st Respondent to address it on its earlier application not to adduce evidence in respect of its case.


- Counsel for 1st Respondent’s submission.


Counsel submitted that having heard the evidence of the Petitioner, they were convinced that the matters in issue cold be sufficiently determined. Counsel cited the Case of Armah v Hydrafoam which held that the Court has no duty to call on a party to testify and by so doing, the Court would be descending into the arena of conflict. Counsel submitted that in any case, the risk of not testifying was one the 1st Respondent bore and the Petitioner ought to be happy since the their testimony remains the only one on record.


- Counsel for the 2nd Respondent’s submission


Counsel associated himself with the submission of Counsel for the 1st Respondent and added that the 2nd Respondent was not making a submission of no case hence all cases from that would be cited in that regard are inapplicable. Counsel proceeded to set out 2nd Respondent’s case and quoted the case Joseph Akonu-Baffoe v Lawrence Buaku to drive home the point that a defendant had no burden to establish in a case and the failure of the Defendant to adduce evidence only means the evidence of the Plaintiff would be the only one to be assessed by the Court. The Petitioner therefore, ought to even be happy at the case of the Respondents. Counsel added further that in any case, the Petitioner had closed his case and C.I. 87 allowed the 2nd Respondent to take the course they were taking.


- Counsel for the Petitioner’s submission.


Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the Respondents, particularly, the 1st Respondent had served a witness statement and by that had committed to testifying. He further submitted that the witness statement had a statement of truth.


The Bench through Justice Marful-Sau and Mariama Owusu queried Counsel several times, on whether the filing of a witness statement amounted to evidence or it becomes evidence when a person is sworn since a witness statement is not sworn evidence. The Court further asked that since petitioner indicated he would call five witnesses but called two, can he be compelled to call the rest.


Counsel insisted on his position as before. Counsel submitted that in the 1st Respondent’s affidavit in opposition to the motion for interrogatories, she had sought to demonstrate she would answer the questions in the interrogatories during cross examination hence she had elected to adduce evidence. 


Counsel also submitted that in the interest of justice, the 1st Respondent should be made to testify and that subsidiary legislation cannot set aside the sacred public duty and need to account.


Counsel finally submitted that if the Respondents were not relying on their witness statements, that there are other options opened to them which they would look to explore. Counsel cited the case of Somalia Biel Biel v Dramani but the court drew Counsel’s attention to the fact that that case was tried on affidavit evidence.


Counsel for 2nd Respondent in his final reply pointed out that the submissions of Counsel for the Petitioner was circular and that by a careful reading of the rules in C.I. 87, a distinction is made between service of witness statement and relying on it hence the argument of Counsel that by serving witness statement, the Respondents had elected to testify could not hold.


Counsel concluded by citing the case of The Society of Lloyds’s v Sir William Otho Jaffray BT to the effect that where a party files a witness statement and does not rely on it, the court had no power to compel the party to testify.

The Court adjourned to Thursday, 11th February, 2021 for its ruling.

Will the Supreme Court allow the EC's chairperson to be cross examined? Let's hear your thoughts by leaving a comment in the comment box below and don't forget to follow up for more information.

Content created and supplied by: AgyarkwahJustice(nanabagist) (via Opera News )

Opera News is a free to use platform and the views and opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not represent, reflect or express the views of Opera News. Any/all written content and images displayed are provided by the blogger/author, appear herein as submitted by the blogger/author and are unedited by Opera News. Opera News does not consent to nor does it condone the posting of any content that violates the rights (including the copyrights) of any third party, nor content that may malign, inter alia, any religion, ethnic group, organization, gender, company, or individual. Opera News furthermore does not condone the use of our platform for the purposes encouraging/endorsing hate speech, violation of human rights and/or utterances of a defamatory nature. If the content contained herein violates any of your rights, including those of copyright, and/or violates any the above mentioned factors, you are requested to immediately notify us using via the following email address operanews-external(at)opera.com and/or report the article using the available reporting functionality built into our Platform

YOU MAY LIKE

Fans react to Lawyer Akoto Ampaw's picture After Kojo Oppong Nkrumah Praised Him On Social Media.

8 minutes ago

66 🔥

Fans react to Lawyer Akoto Ampaw's picture After Kojo Oppong Nkrumah Praised Him On Social Media.

Aseidu Nketia made it easier for us to win the case-John Boadu (NPP secretary)

15 minutes ago

74 🔥

Aseidu Nketia made it easier for us to win the case-John Boadu (NPP secretary)

The new dance of the NPP after winning the petition yesterday.

17 minutes ago

211 🔥

The new dance of the NPP after winning the petition yesterday.

Kwesi Pratt Jnr's Daughter is the Manager of His TV Station. See 18 beautiful PICS

33 minutes ago

199 🔥

Kwesi Pratt Jnr's Daughter is the Manager of His TV Station. See 18 beautiful PICS

How Kumasi Prophet boldly predicted Supreme Court ruling on Mahama's petition word for word

43 minutes ago

240 🔥

How Kumasi Prophet boldly predicted Supreme Court ruling on Mahama's petition word for word

A Man Was Arrested For Kidnapping Three Children.

48 minutes ago

269 🔥

A Man Was Arrested For Kidnapping Three Children.

Meet Gen Nunoo Mensah, Ex Army Commander, Chief Of Defense Staff And Revolutionary Pal Of Rawlings

1 hours ago

20 🔥

Meet Gen Nunoo Mensah, Ex Army Commander, Chief Of Defense Staff And Revolutionary Pal Of Rawlings

Report From The Supreme Court - Details

1 hours ago

58 🔥

Report From The Supreme Court - Details

'Stolen Car' found at Kasoa Kuwait after five years of missing

1 hours ago

767 🔥

'Stolen Car' found at Kasoa Kuwait after five years of missing

Real stories from women on the advice of their Doctors not to take the vaccines- Bridget Otoo

1 hours ago

30 🔥

Real stories from women on the advice of their Doctors not to take the vaccines- Bridget Otoo

COMMENTS

View all comments