Opera News

Opera News App

Today In Court - Details

AgyarkwahJustice(nanabagist)
By AgyarkwahJustice(nanabagist) | self meida writer
Published 9 days ago - 1919 views

Hearing commenced today at 10:00am. After parties and Counsel announced themselves, Counsel for petitioner informed the Court that a point of law had arisen yesterday during his reply to 2nd respondent’s submissions and he had that morning served letters on parties intended to allow him address that point since it would be crucial in the decision of the Court. He further added that he had attached a list of authorities he intended to rely on.

The Court speaking through the Chief Justice informed petitioner’s Counsel that the matters he intended to argue were matters of law which the Court had already taken cognisance of hence would proceed to deliver their ruling.


The Court in its ruling recounted the circumstances leading to petitioner’s application for leave to re-open case to subpoena the Chairperson of 1st respondent. The Court noted that it was Counsel for petitioner who informed the court he didn’t intend to call any further witnesses hence had closed petitioner’s case following which the respondents were called to open their case. The respondents decided not to open their case since in their view, insufficient evidence had been led in support of the petition. Consequently, they prayed the Court to close their case but this was fiercely resisted by the petitioner’s Counsel and the court after addresses by the parties gave a ruling on 11-02-21. The Court noted that indeed it was this ruling that triggered the application to re-open case as admitted in paragraphs 15, 16 and 17 of petitioner’s affidavit in support.


The Court noted that the application had been brought under the inherent power of the court and therefore the petitioner ought to demonstrate why the exercise of that discretion should be in their favour.


The Court stated that the argument that they want the Chairperson to be subpoenaed to vindicate herself was untenable as the Chairperson was not on trial in the matter before the Court. It was the Electoral Commission as an institution, which had been sued for some constitutional breaches and that the Court did not think that the petitioner required the presence of the Chairperson to prove that some unconstitutionality had occurred.


The Court observed that its inherent jurisdiction is exercised in certain circumstances but the petitioner had failed to demonstrate any miscarriage of justice that has occasioned him as a result of the decision of the 1st respondent not to testify through its Chair. Additionally, the petitioner had failed to demonstrate which evidence he intended to solicit from the Chair of the EC to warrant the exercise of the Court’s discretion in his favour.


The Court continued that an application to re-open case is granted in exceptional circumstances and a decision to grant such an application must be subject to a scrupulous balancing act between the parties. The Court referred to the cases of Komabt v Lambim and the Canadian case of Ontario Limited v Sagaz, all of which were cited by 2nd respondent’s Counsel in his submissions.


The Court also referred to the cases of Poku v Poku where Wood CJ(as she then was) advised that granting leave to adduce fresh evidence was not meant to aid the indolent, reckless, or negligent litigant who fails to marshall all the essential facts in support of his case and comes back to seek another opportunity to build the case. Annobil v Obosu was also cited, all of which were mentioned by counsel for 2nd respondent in his submissions.


The Court stated that in all the cases cited, the defendants had testified and their testimony warranted the re-opening of the case for Plaintiff to lead some further evidence. Since the 1st respondent through its Chair had elected not to testify, no case had been made by petitioner on why the case he voluntarily closed should be re-opened.


The Court concluded that that petitioner had failed to give an inkling of the fresh evidence he intended to adduce and how it was going to help the Court in dealing with the issues set for trial.


Accordingly, the application to re-open case to enable EC Chair to testify was dismissed.


Petitoner’s Counsel informed the Court that they were in the process of filing a review to the decision of the Court dated 11-02-21 but the Court stated that its earlier orders on filing closing addresses and returning on Thursday stood unless the matter was scheduled by the registry to a different date.


Case therefore stands adjourned to Thursday, 18/02/21.

Content created and supplied by: AgyarkwahJustice(nanabagist) (via Opera News )

Tags:      

Court
Opera News is a free to use platform and the views and opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not represent, reflect or express the views of Opera News. Any/all written content and images displayed are provided by the blogger/author, appear herein as submitted by the blogger/author and are unedited by Opera News. Opera News does not consent to nor does it condone the posting of any content that violates the rights (including the copyrights) of any third party, nor content that may malign, inter alia, any religion, ethnic group, organization, gender, company, or individual. Opera News furthermore does not condone the use of our platform for the purposes encouraging/endorsing hate speech, violation of human rights and/or utterances of a defamatory nature. If the content contained herein violates any of your rights, including those of copyright, and/or violates any the above mentioned factors, you are requested to immediately notify us using via the following email address operanews-external(at)opera.com and/or report the article using the available reporting functionality built into our Platform

YOU MAY LIKE

Top 10 Celebs That Were Involved In Serious Car Accidents

2 minutes ago

0 🔥

Top 10 Celebs That Were Involved In Serious Car Accidents

21-year old LGBTQI boy boldly tells his story on Angel TV

4 minutes ago

0 🔥

21-year old LGBTQI boy boldly tells his story on Angel TV

Great News! Funny Face Reunites With Adebayor. Watch Video.

10 minutes ago

0 🔥

Great News! Funny Face Reunites With Adebayor. Watch Video.

Road Accidents Have Killed More People Than Covid-19 - Ghanaians React To Gory Accident This Morning

31 minutes ago

130 🔥

Road Accidents Have Killed More People Than Covid-19 - Ghanaians React To Gory Accident This Morning

After This Man Saved A Pregnant Woman From A Crocodile Attack, See What People Want For Him

37 minutes ago

31 🔥

After This Man Saved A Pregnant Woman From A Crocodile Attack, See What People Want For Him

A Junior High School Teacher assaulted

39 minutes ago

23 🔥

A Junior High School Teacher assaulted

Sankore based VIP bus involves in a fatal accident at Akim Asafo, kills 24, others severely injured.

39 minutes ago

103 🔥

Sankore based VIP bus involves in a fatal accident at Akim Asafo, kills 24, others severely injured.

Meet some gospel musician whose marriage to pastors ended in tears

45 minutes ago

43 🔥

Meet some gospel musician whose marriage to pastors ended in tears

Boil 10 Slices Of Paw- Paw Leaf With Guava Leaf, Drink For 7 Days And Get Healed Of This Disease

1 hours ago

55 🔥

Boil 10 Slices Of Paw- Paw Leaf With Guava Leaf, Drink For 7 Days And Get Healed Of This Disease

The Family Of Funny Face Has Betrayed Kwaku Painfully, I Feel There Is An Agenda Somewhere-Sammy

1 hours ago

51 🔥

The Family Of Funny Face Has Betrayed Kwaku Painfully, I Feel There Is An Agenda Somewhere-Sammy

COMMENTS

View all comments