Opera News

Opera News App

Build Your Case, On Your Evidence's Strength and Not on the Weakness of the Respondents Evidence- SC

newsbreak21
By newsbreak21 | self meida writer
Published 15 days ago - 0 views

The election petition filed by the Petitioner Mr. John Mahama is taking an interesting turn if events unfolding at the supreme court is anything to go by.

The petitoner filed a new processes in court seeking the leave of the court to reopen his case and then subpoena Madam Jean Mensah to testify in a new –page document filed at the supreme court moments after the court overruled its objection against the decision of the EC chairperson not to testify.

The lawyers for the petitioner says they believed Jean Mensah would be testifying on oath until she decided otherwise, earlier the supreme court in a unanimous decision upheld the application by the first and second respondents not to call any witnesses in the ongoing election petition hearing.

The decision by the apex court follows oral arguments made by the lawyers for the electoral commission and president Akufo Addo that their clients cannot be compelled to testify after the petitioner closed their case in court.

Lawyers for the EC to the surprise of many announced that madam Jean Mensah will not testify and that they also closing their case prompting an objection from lawyers from Mr Mahama.

According to Mr Kwadwo Oppong Nkrumah minister for information designate and a spoke person for the second respondent legal team, here’s what happened in court the supreme court in its ruling framed the issue before it for determination as whether or not respondents can be compelled to give evidence.

The court held that witness statements do not constitute evidence until the witness enters the box and takes the oath to indicate reliance on it. This is against the background that Mr Tsatsu had argued that by filing a witness statement the EC chairperson had elected to give testimony, moreover the supreme court in it’s unanimous ruling asserts that the law is settled, that the positions in affidavits filed in court does not constitute evidence before the court.

EC in its affidavit in opposition to an earlier demand by the petitioner to serve interrogatories stated that those questions could be asked during cross-examination.

The law is therefore settled that the party will not be compared to enter the witness box and testify in support of her case, even though she has submitted evidence, which the court explained that, that was a requirement by the court for her to submit evidence to plead her case, that does not amount to she electing to adduce evidence in court and she can so choose not to. 

The court further ruled that “ an election petition also deals with witnesses who have served witness statements and have decided not to give evidence to be cross-examined we are minded to state that our jurisdiction as invoked in this election petition is a limited jurisdiction.

Clearly circumscribed by law we do not intend to extend our mandate beyond what the law requires us. If a petition is brought challenging the validity of the election of a president we expect the line of arguments and evidence to be provided, simply put we are not convinced and will  not yield to the invitation being extended by counsel for the petitioner to order the respondent to enter the witness box. Accordingly we hereby overruled the obvious objection by counsel for the petitioner against the decision of the respondents, declining to induce evidence in this petition.

According to the court, the petitioner's case should stand or fail based on the strength of his case and not on the weakness of the respondents case.

The petitioner's lawyers Mr Tsatsu and Mr Tony lithur have served notice that they will be filing for a review of the case.

They will be filing an application to subpoena the chairperson of the electoral commission to answer some questions, they have been at pain to explain that they are not trying to shift the burden of proof onto the electoral commission but they are saying that as the constitutionally mandated body to organize the election and the chairperson being the returning officer of the election it is important that she takes the box to answer certain pertinent questions concerning the December 2020 general elections.

We wait to see how the new twist to the court proceedings pan out.

Content created and supplied by: newsbreak21 (via Opera News )

Opera News is a free to use platform and the views and opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not represent, reflect or express the views of Opera News. Any/all written content and images displayed are provided by the blogger/author, appear herein as submitted by the blogger/author and are unedited by Opera News. Opera News does not consent to nor does it condone the posting of any content that violates the rights (including the copyrights) of any third party, nor content that may malign, inter alia, any religion, ethnic group, organization, gender, company, or individual. Opera News furthermore does not condone the use of our platform for the purposes encouraging/endorsing hate speech, violation of human rights and/or utterances of a defamatory nature. If the content contained herein violates any of your rights, including those of copyright, and/or violates any the above mentioned factors, you are requested to immediately notify us using via the following email address operanews-external(at)opera.com and/or report the article using the available reporting functionality built into our Platform

YOU MAY LIKE

Massive Throwback Photo As LGBTQ Dates Back To 1978.

24 minutes ago

6 🔥

Massive Throwback Photo As LGBTQ Dates Back To 1978.

Meet The Pretty Female Carpenter

33 minutes ago

0 🔥

Meet The Pretty Female Carpenter

7 Spiritual Habits That Will Help You Grow Spiritually And Increase You

36 minutes ago

9 🔥

7 Spiritual Habits That Will Help You Grow Spiritually And Increase You

"I don't support them but I aIso don't think it's right to attack"- Kwame A- Plus

43 minutes ago

18 🔥

Here's How Much Kelvyn Boy, Akwaboah And Fameye Charge For A Feature

52 minutes ago

5 🔥

Here's How Much Kelvyn Boy, Akwaboah And Fameye Charge For A Feature

This Comment From Kwaw Kesse To Prez Nana Addo Might Land Him In Trouble- Opinion

1 hours ago

18 🔥

This Comment From Kwaw Kesse To Prez Nana Addo Might Land Him In Trouble- Opinion

In any serious country, these buses would be grounded and investigated - Kwame A-Plus fumes

1 hours ago

485 🔥

In any serious country, these buses would be grounded and investigated - Kwame A-Plus fumes

Photos Of Gospel Musician Gifty Osei Flaunting Her Curvy Backside In Her Green Outfit

1 hours ago

33 🔥

Photos Of Gospel Musician Gifty Osei Flaunting Her Curvy Backside In Her Green Outfit

Homemade Soy Milk Recipe

1 hours ago

13 🔥

Homemade Soy Milk Recipe

Watch these photos that shows nature is extremely beautiful

2 hours ago

59 🔥

Watch these photos that shows nature is extremely beautiful

COMMENTS