Most Orientalists and their lackeys claim that in the early days of Islam, especially in the period of the Khulafa ar-Rashidun', writing and compilation was uncommon; rather it was banned. Sayings of the Holy Prophet that discouraged writing and compilation were also narrated.However, slowly, as Islam spread to other places, compilation and writing became the norm. Traditions that encouraged and recommended writing and compilation were narrated by the Prophet.
George Zeidan says: "The Khulafa ar-Rashidun were afraid of the urbanization of the Arabs. They believed that urbanization would cause the Arabs to lose their naivety and simplicity and for this reason, they prevented the Arabs from writing and compiling books.
However, slowly the Islamic kingdom spread and the companions migrated to different places; disturbances between the Muslims and differing views and beliefs led to more consultations with scholars.Muslims were left with no choice but to compile the ahadith, jurisprudence and Qur'anic sciences and they resorted to analysis, proof and inquiry. and in this not only did they take writing to be a disliked act, but rather they took it to be a recommended and quoted the ahadith that were narrated by Anas ibn Malik from the Holy Prophet."
That which George Zeidan attributes to the rightly guided caliphs' is an outright lie. Neither has the issue of urbanization been mentioned nor the prohibition of writing or compiling that George Zeidan repeatedly alludes to.
The issues that have been expounded by George Zeidan and others are to do with the prohibition of the companions of the Holy Prophet from leaving Medina and settling in another place. Secondly, the prohibition of writing the ahadith of the Holy Prophet and both of these are attributable only to the second caliph and not all the caliphs were known as rightly guided.We see that it has been recorded in history that Ali and some other companions were on one side and Umar with some other companions was on the other side on the issue of writing down the ahadith of the Holy Prophet and we are going to discuss this issue later. On the issue of leaving Medina and settling elsewhere, we know that Ali moved his headquarters from Medina to Kufa and other companions also migrated.
Therefore, George Zeidan's statements are baseless. Edward Brown also claims that in the first century of Hijra, while the Muslims had an extraordinary enthusiasm for learning, no books were written. All the knowledge was passed on from person to person and generation to generation orally and the Qur'an was about the only written literature that had remained with the Arabs. He writes: "It was only possible to gain knowledge (in the first century of Hijra) by travelling and this also was done only rarely and only when necessary.Every journey had its difficulties and many arrangements would need to be made before travelling. Gradually, travelling became the norm and eventually, it became a type of insanity and ahadith like the following encouraged travelling to gain knowledge: The Prophet said, 'Anyone who travels for the sake of seeking knowledge, Allah will take him to the path that leads to paradise.'
Makhul was a slave in Egypt who, when set free, was not willing to travel out of the kingdom but once he had learnt all the basic teachings in Egypt, he got inspired and travelled to Hijaz, Iraq and Syria to find a reliable hadith about the division of war booty This view, however, is baseless.
After a more thorough investigation about the relics from the early days of Islam, it becomes evident that writing had commenced from the time of the Holy Prophet and it continued.Plenty of evidence exists to prove this. In the footnotes of the Farsi translation of Brown's History of Literature (Vol.1) views like Brown's and the proof against such views have been presented' from the 'Writings of the Shia al-Imamiyya fil Ulum al-Islamiyya' by the Late Allama Shaykh al-Islam Zanjani'.
Similarly, the great scholar Late Ayatullah Hassan Sadr (May Allah raise his status) in his very valuable work "Ta'sees as-Shi'a li Ulum al-Islam's disproves this view. In our coming discussions, we will elaborate further on this point as we have briefly discussed it.
Content created and supplied by: Ginola14 (via Opera News )
Opera News is a free to use platform and the views and opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not represent, reflect or express the views of Opera News. Any/all written content and images displayed are provided by the blogger/author, appear herein as submitted by the blogger/author and are unedited by Opera News. Opera News does not consent to nor does it condone the posting of any content that violates the rights (including the copyrights) of any third party, nor content that may malign, inter alia, any religion, ethnic group, organization, gender, company, or individual. Opera News furthermore does not condone the use of our platform for the purposes encouraging/endorsing hate speech, violation of human rights and/or utterances of a defamatory nature. If the content contained herein violates any of your rights, including those of copyright, and/or violates any the above mentioned factors, you are requested to immediately notify us using via the following email address operanews-external(at)opera.com and/or report the article using the available reporting functionality built into our Platform See More